Window Repair vs Replacement

Windows · 6 min read

Nobody should sell you twelve new windows when three need new glass and one needs a new balance. Just as often, people spend money fixing a window whose frame is soft and will be back to the same problem in a few years.

Here is how we sort it out, window by window.

What Repair Can Fix

If the frame and sash are sound, most of these are fixed without touching the trim or the siding.

  • A broken or cracked pane
  • A foggy insulated glass unit, replaced in the existing sash
  • Worn weatherstripping and seals
  • Worn balances on double-hung windows
  • Stripped cranks, locks, and hinges on casements
  • Loose or missing glazing putty on old wood sash
  • Broken glass and worn screens on storm windows

When Replacement Is the Better Money

  • The frame or sill is soft or rotted
  • Several sealed units are failing on the same old windows
  • Parts are no longer made for your window
  • The frame is out of square and nothing closes cleanly
  • You want a different style, like casement in place of a slider
  • The house is full of single-pane glass with no storms

Why Glass Repair Is Often Enough

A window is a frame, a sash, the hardware, and the glass. When only one of those has failed, replacing all four is usually more than the problem calls for. Broken and foggy glass are common problems, and in a sound sash they are fixed by replacing the glass alone.

A new sealed unit can include Low-E and argon, so a window that was built before those were common can come out of a glass repair performing better than it did new. The frame does not change, which is the limit on how far that improvement goes.

The Decision Table

SituationUsually repairUsually replace
One broken pane, sound frameYes
One or two foggy unitsYes, glass only
Foggy units all over an old window lineCompare both
Drafts from worn weatherstrippingYes
Drafts from a warped sash or shifted frameYes
Sash drops or won’t crank, parts availableYes
Parts discontinuedYes
Soft spot on the sash onlyOften
Rot in the frame or sillYes
Original wood sash in good shapeYes, plus storms

Old Wood Windows Are a Special Case

Many older houses in Superior and Duluth still have their original wood sash. When the wood is sound, those windows can often be reglazed, tightened up, and paired with good storm windows for a real gain in comfort. Our storm windows page covers that route.

If your house is locally designated as historic, repair is often the simpler path on paper as well. The notes in the questions below cover both cities.

The Cost of Waiting

Some problems can sit. A foggy unit will not damage the house, and a stiff sash is an annoyance, not an emergency. Others get worse. Water getting past a failed sill or a cracked pane can rot the wood around it, and a small repair can grow into a replacement if it waits through another winter.

If you are not sure which kind you have, look for staining, soft wood, or peeling paint below the window. Those are the signs that time is working against you.

How We Help You Decide

  1. We look at each window, not just the one you called about
  2. We check the frame and sill for soft wood
  3. We note which problems are glass-only fixes
  4. We price repair and replacement side by side where both make sense
  5. You decide, with the full price in writing

Where To Go From Here

Start with window repair if you think the fix is small, or window replacement if the frames are going. For broken glass anywhere in the house, see glass repair. Every job is backed by our Promise Plan: honest pricing, on time, work we’re proud of, a clean job site, and if something isn’t right, we fix it.

Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

The Census Bureau’s 2020-2024 American Community Survey estimates about 43% of Duluth’s homes and about 36% of Superior’s were built in 1939 or earlier. The median build year is 1951 in Duluth and 1957 in Superior. That is a lot of original wood windows, and many are still repairable.

On locally designated properties, work that changes the exterior appearance needs a historic construction permit. The city code says ordinary maintenance and repair of exterior elements is not prevented. Confirm with the City of Duluth planning office before starting.

Six properties are on Superior’s municipal historic register. For those, exterior alterations need a certificate of appropriateness, and city staff can issue it for storm window and storm door repair or replacement. Other window work goes to the Historic Preservation Committee.

The new sealed unit can often include Low-E and argon, so the glass can match or beat what you had. The frame stays the same, so a new window will usually outperform it overall.

Yes. We offer 0% interest up to 365 days same-as-cash on approved credit.

Get Started Today

Repair Or Replace? Let’s Look.

We will look at each window, tell you honestly which can be fixed, and put both prices in writing.