Drafty Windows in a Northland Winter

Problem Guide · 7 min read

Is It Really A Draft?

Not every cold spot by a window is a leak. Glass on a January night is much colder than the room. Air next to it cools, gets heavier, and slides down the pane to the floor, pulling warmer room air in behind it. That loop feels exactly like a draft on your ankles, even when the window is sealed tight.

The difference matters because the fixes are different. A true air leak needs sealing. A cold-glass draft needs warmer glass: a storm window, a better sealed unit, or a new window. The test below tells you which one you have.

How To Find The Leak

The U.S. Department of Energy’s Energy Saver guide recommends a simple smoke test on a windy day. Here’s the version we’d use at home:

  1. Pick a windy day. Close every window and exterior door.
  2. Turn on the bath fans and the range hood. Pulling air out of the house makes leaks draw harder and easier to spot.
  3. Hold a lit incense stick close to the edges of each sash, the meeting rail where the two sashes overlap, the lock, the sill, and the inside trim.
  4. Watch the smoke. If it streams sideways or gets pulled toward the window, you’ve found a leak. If it rises straight up but the area still feels cold, the glass is the issue.
  5. Look for daylight around the sash, and try to rattle it. A sash that moves in its frame is likely leaking air.
  6. Mark each leak with painter’s tape so you remember where they are.

Weatherstripping, Sash, Frame, Or Glass?

Where the cold comes inLikely causeTypical fix
Along the edges of the sashWorn, flattened, or missing weatherstrippingNew weatherstripping sized to the gap
At the meeting rail and lockSash lock not pulling the rails together, or a warped sashAdjust or replace the lock; repair the sash
Around the inside trimGap between the window frame and the wallCaulk the trim, and insulate the gap if accessible
Old double-hung sidesOpen sash-weight pockets and pulley holesSeal or insulate the pockets, or add a storm
No moving air, just coldSingle-pane glass or a failed sealed unitStorm window, new sealed unit, or new window
Sash won’t close fullySwelling, rot, or a frame out of squareSash repair or window replacement

Quick Fixes Before The Snow Flies

The rule of thumb: caulk for joints that don’t move, like trim and frames, and weatherstripping for parts that do, like sashes and doors. DOE’s Energy Saver guide estimates that sealing uncontrolled air leaks can save 10 to 20% on heating and cooling bills.

  • V-strip or foam weatherstripping on the sash edges and meeting rail
  • Removable rope caulk on windows you won’t open until spring
  • Shrink-film plastic kits on the interior trim of the worst windows
  • Insulated cellular shades, closed at night and opened by day to let the sun in
  • Fresh caulk where interior trim has pulled away from the wall

Storm Windows: The Underrated Fix

Plenty of homes in Superior and Duluth still have original wood windows. Many of those sashes are old-growth wood worth keeping, and a good storm window turns them into a far better assembly. DOE’s Energy Saver guide says low-e storm windows, interior or exterior, can save 10 to 30% on heating and cooling costs depending on the window already in place, and that they should have weatherstripping at all movable joints.

A storm window also cuts the wind that drives leaks and adds a pocket of still air in front of the glass. Our storm windows page covers the styles and how they’re fitted.

When Replacement Makes Sense

Weatherstripping and storms go a long way, but some windows are past it. Consider replacement windows when the sills or sash bottoms are soft, when several sealed units have fogged, when sashes won’t operate or lock, or when the frame is out of square and nothing seals. Today’s energy-efficient windows pair insulated Low-E glass with tight weatherstripping built in, which addresses the air leak and the cold glass at the same time. If the drafty window is also icing up, read why ice forms on the inside of windows.

Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

More than in most places. NOAA’s 1991-2020 normals count about 8,822 heating degree days a year at the Superior weather station and 9,115 at the Duluth airport, with average January lows of 5.8°F and 2.4°F. Every leak is working against a long, cold heating season.

They help most over single-pane and poorly performing windows. DOE puts low-e storm window savings at 10 to 30% depending on the window already installed, so the payoff over a sound double-pane is smaller.

Superior’s code requires a certificate of appropriateness for exterior changes to properties on the municipal register, but it lets city staff approve storm window and storm door repair or replacement without a full committee review (Sec. 98-90(b)(7)). Other window changes go to the committee.

For locally designated Duluth landmarks and districts, work that changes the exterior appearance needs a historic construction permit, while ordinary maintenance and repair is exempt. Check with the City of Duluth planning office before changing windows on a designated property.

Use removable rope caulk or a shrink-film kit rather than permanent caulk on a window that opens. Permanent caulk on a sash makes it hard to open in spring and can be an egress problem in a bedroom.

Yes. Cold glass chills the air beside it, which sinks and pulls room air across the window. The smoke test tells you the difference: moving smoke means a leak, steady smoke means cold glass.

Get Started Today

Still Feeling The Cold?

Tell us which windows and what you’ve found. We’ll check the sash, the seals, and the glass, and give you a straight answer and a written price.